Mulligans Vs Side Pot

[sturmgeist]

This is what I want to do:

Give each card a mulligan bag - if a player wants a mulligan on a shot, he announces his intentions, deposits $2 into the bag, and takes his shot. If someone wants to spend $10 putting in the wind on the hill out there, then god bless them, and as a result I hope you ALL play like crap.

I think this should be about charity and having fun, and anyone coming to this for serious competition is coming to the wrong place. There's still gonna be plenty of competition and it's going to be extremely cut throat, but the competition isn't the focus.

I say we just do the unlimited mulligans and side pot as planned, and if someone wants to buy a win, then so be it, somebody might end up spending more than what they get in payout.

[AveSatani]

I would rather have unlimited mulligans than a side pot.

[Jrodisc]

I think both would be good. The side pot should be big enough for the guys to want to buy mully after mully trying to win it.

[chessguy]

This will be very fun AND interesting!!! The side pot thing will be quite interesting. I thought about a couple of things; 1) so we can use as many mulligans as we want on any stroke? That is huge. Ex. 3 putts to make a 15 footer will cost $4. cool :D It would be completely different however to limit mulligans to use one per stroke. 2) to be able to pay for mulligans at the time you want to use one is big also as opposed to say purchasing 10 of them before play for $20 3) I guess you wouldn't want to limit mulligan use to 1 per hole.

Lot's of intersting ins n outs but as it is it seems that it will be unlimited, purchase at time of need, and use as many per stroke as needed. Correct?

I'm glad to see we are doing an Icebowl to benefit the Food Bank.

Do you think -15 will be doable???

It is important to keep in mind that the one who is willing to purchase more mulligans is perfectly content to making donations to the cause. SWEET!!! win/win

[dg]

it is conceivable that someone could spend more money on mulligans than they win for 1'st place, lmao!!!

but the trophy makes it worth it